Simple Shark Cookies

Working with what you have…it’s a simple notion, but not always easy for a person like me.  Often, when I have a idea I’m not satisfied until I’ve recreated exactly what I see in my head.

In a perfect world I wouldn’t live eighty miles from everything I need.  But since I do, I’ve had to learn to be creative with my available materials and supplies.  Which brings me to these sharks.

Simple Shark CookiesCan you believe that the girl who owns thousands of cutters has only one shark cookie cutter?  True story.  This is the one from the Wilton Animal Pals set.

It works but I don’t love the fact that it doesn’t have a bottom fin.  Instead of hand cutting, piecing, or paying shipping on a single cutter, I decided to make it work.

I sometimes have to remind myself  that special cutters aren’t a requirement for exceptional cookies.

Simple Shark Cookies 1Before baking I used the cutter to mark a fin on the unbaked cookie.

Simple Shark Cookies 2You can still see the design after baking.  This technique is great for people without a projector because it takes the guesswork out of piping.

Simple Shark Cookies 4Now you’re ready to decorate.  To make this cookie you will need:

Use gray piping icing with a #2 tip to outline the cookie as shown below.

Simple Shark Cookies 5Use white 20-second icing to fill the belly area.

Simple Shark Cookies 6Flood the top portion of the shark and use tweezers to carefully add an eye.

Simple Shark Cookies 7Add gills and pipe around the gray area to finish up.  Let dry for 8-10 hours or overnight.

Simple Shark Cookies 9With a little creativity, you can transform even the simplest cutter into something a little more personalized and unique.  Color and other  cookie designs add even more visual appeal.  I used tutorials from some of my favorite cookie decorators to round out this set.

Shark Cookies and SurfersHere are some of my favorites!

Surfing and Shark Cookies_SweetsugarbelleBe sure to hop on over to I Heart Naptime and learn how to make simple shark fin cupcake toppers to round out the theme.

Shark Fin Cupcake Toppers_SweetsugarbelleFor more tips on making cookies like these, check out the following links:

Join The Discussion



  1. 31
    Anne S. says:

    Can you tell me what cutter you used to make the shark that is facing the front? I love it!!!

  2. 32
    TriciaZ says:

    EEEEEEK!!!! SHARK WEEK!!! Love these!!

  3. 33

    That surfboard with the chomp mark really makes this set stand out! Just the surfboard part is wonderful but the bite mark is really neat! Thanks for sharing! : )

  4. 34
    patty says:

    These are soooo cute! U r amazing! Which cookie cutter did u use for the shark head and the boy? Thanks!


  1. […] Simple Shark Cookies […]

  2. […] 2. Impossibly adorable cookies. I love the little bites taken out of the surfboards and swim trunks! by Sugarbelle […]

  3. […] Simple shark cookies  (Sugarbelle) […]

  4. […] Lowe’s “So Sharky” Commercial Shark Cookies by Sweet Sugar Belle Shark Mouth Cookies by Sweet Sugar Belle Shark Cupcakes by Joann Shark Week Watermelon Shark by […]

  5. […] Approved DIY Shark Themed Jewelry via Dollar Store Crafts  Shark Week Nails via the Refinery Simple Shark Cookies via Sugarbelle Shark Watermelon via Babble Shark Cupcakes via A Baked […]

  6. […] Simple Shark Cookies […]

  7. […] you’re planning a summer shark-themed party, be sure to check out how-to decorate simple shark cookies over on my blog. Thank you for having me today, Jamielyn. Happy Baking! Follow my blog with […]