Toadstool Cookies from Simple Cutters

Funny thing about Alice and rabbits…they can show up ANYWHERE.  Mushrooms too!  This happens to me all the time.  I look at my grass and there’s nothing there, then the next morning there’s a toadstool where there wasn’t one before.

Just like their natural counterpart, mushroom cookies also have a way of popping up out of nowhere.

Toadstool or Mushroom Cookie Okay, I might be exaggerating a little.  They do come from somewhere, but luckily, just like real ones it doesn’t take much.  If you have any of these cutters…an egg, circle, or candy corn, then you’ve got a toadstool.

Toadstool Cookie CuttersSimply cut the shape and take a notch out of each side with a heart cutter.  I like this wonky one from Wilton.

Easy Mushroom CookiesTada!  An entire collection of toadstools with basic cutters!

Alice in Wonderland Cookie PlatterFor tips on making the rest of the cookies in this collection, check out these links:

Join The Discussion


Current ye@r *


  1. 11
    Paula says:

    Love the beautiful assortment shown here Callye and I’m just shake my head seeing how you create such new and wonderfully fun cookies out of cutters that started out to be something totally different.

  2. 12
    Cora says:

    Oh, this is brilliant! I’ve been looking into other uses for my cutters because I am out. of. room. for new ones and have really been wanting mushroom cutters for some reason. I love the sheer amount of variation that’s possible with this, that you couldn’t get with just a single toadstool cutter.