Organizing Cookie Cutters {WFMW}

Okay, you’ve set aside a few hours, you have all of the ingredients, and a ton of  ideas then suddenly, all activity comes screeching to a halt.  It’s time to play “Find That Cutter”.  The next hour is spent searching, usually in vain, for that elusive [insert shape] cutter, you saw only last week!

Sound familiar?

I own a LOT of cookie cutters.  And by a lot, I mean WELL over a thousand.  This is not really necessary, I mean really, you can do almost anything in the world with just a few square and round cutters, but I CANNOT STOP collecting them!

Problem is, I’m almost as good at losing cutters as I am at making cookies.

To save my sanity, and maybe my husband’s also, I had to come up with an organized way to store my rapidly growing cutter collection.

I’d love to tell you that I have a miracle way of fitting a thousand plus cutters in a 6×6 space {and so would my husband} but the truth is, my hobby takes a little bit of space. 

In my case, I’ve taken over our dining room.  Thank goodness we have a breakfast bar…

So, here it is. This is my cookie cutter collection.  PLEASE forgive me if you ever ask me where a cutter is from and I cannot remember.   At this point I can barely remember if I HAVE a certain shape, much less where I got it from.

What’s even crazier is, if you look closely you can see my collection is even beginning to trickle onto another set of shelves…but that’s a story for another day.


To store my cutters, I use two different sized bins, small ones like this


and larger ones like these.


To break them down even further, I divide them into categories that work for me.   A few of  these are: baby, sports, flowers, stars, and luau, but that is just the beginning.  There are many many more.

 If you need ideas for organizing, it might be helpful to head over to a site like Off the Beaten Path, {which also happens to be one of my favorite cookie cutter stores} to look at their categories.  You can use this as sort of a jumping off point and tweak it from there.

In case you are wondering why I use two different sized bins, this is the reason.  For broad categories, such as sports, the larger bins work great.  However, from time to time they can outgrow themselves, especially categories like Christmas.  In this case, I just divide the larger categories into subcategories.  For example, instead of a huge Christmas bin, I have several smaller bins.  One is trees. There are others that house several smaller categories that I associate with one another such as Santa and Rudolph or wreaths and holly.  Make sense? 

Of course, specifics may vary slightly from person to person, but I am *reasonably* confident that is you walked into my workroom for the very first time, you’d have a good chance of finding what you’re looking for.

To further simplify cutter hunting, I borrowed my hubby’s label maker and made removable labels for each bin.  Its better not to do this with something like a permanent marker so that it’s easier for bins to change as your collection does, and believe me, if you like cookie-ing as much as I do, it WILL.

Speaking of things not to do, meet the Basket of DOOM!  This is one of my many habits that annoys my husband beyond belief.  Sometimes I get in a rush and instead of immediately putting cutters away, I dump them all into this basket, which is great, UNTIL one basket turns into two and my husband I spend a whole Sunday putting them back where they belong!

So, avoid the day long organizing session, on DON’T do this!

Well, this is it, my cookie cutter collection, and where I keep them all! This storage method works well for me.  I love the bins because I can carry them from the dining room into the kitchen and back without a hassle. 

Whether you think flip flops belong in the luau box or the shoe and feet box, your cutters will be organized and ready to go when you need them.

This is only one part of my cookie room, the room formerly known as the dining room.  If you want to see more, let me know, I’d love to give y’all the grand tour!

I hope this storage solution works for you too.  Happy Wednesday everyone!

Join The Discussion


Current day month ye@r *


  1. 91
    hpotter says:

    You’ve inspired me!
    I love the Chippendale cookies and know I don’t have that cutter, but when I saw the giraffes… oh, now I had to go looking for what could be used. I pulled down my two containers of cookie cutters and no luck. I need to go buy a pump rounded bottom snowman and a gift box :)
    My husband saw the 50 metal/vintage cutters I had and thought that was alot, wait until he sees this.
    Keep it up.

  2. 92
    Andrea says:

    Man, and I thought I had a lot of cutters at around 200! Recently I took the bull by the horns and made an Excel spreadsheet with mine listed by shape and category-it works for me!

  3. 93

    This is awesome and I would LOVE to see more of the cookie room!

  4. 94
    Cynthia Ralph says:

    Tour of your cookie room would be fantabulous!

  5. 95
    Sweet Tooth says:

    OMG! you’re so organized!

  6. 96
    Lynda says:

    I love you. . . I mean it’s so cool to see a collection this size. Categorizing my 400 or so piece collection a couple of years ago into separate containers made using the cutters fun again. Have entertained thoughts of parting with them, even lent them out one time, each day imagining “what if what if . . . “. Now I think so what if I only use them occasionally -I love having them. Thanks for sharing your collection !

  7. 97
    Mindy says:

    Jaw still on the floor!

  8. 98
    renata says:

    I loved your organization. I´m trying to do that. As a beginner, I have only 4 box with (almost) all my culinary stuff (color gels, cutters, pens, etc) but my husband is already a little upset with that, because they are in the dinning room. Anyway, I´ve made a trip to Italy and bought a lot of new stuffs (and cutters!). They are still on the table waiting for another box be bought… :) I hope my husband don’t get more upset…

  9. 99
    Kailin says:

    It’s a pleasure to find such ranittalioy in an answer. Welcome to the debate.


  1. [...] Organizing Cookie Cutters – Now that’s a lot of cookie cutters! [...]

  2. [...] cookies? Fill with cookie cutters like Sweet Adventures of Sugarbelle [...]

  3. [...] make this easy I chose a tulip cutter for this project since I know that not everyone has over a thousand cookie cutters like I [...]

  4. [...] know the last thing I need is another cookie cutter, but I could not resist these.   I guess it’s Betty Crocker’s version of [...]

  5. [...] guess I would probably be embarrassed.  Between this and my cookie cutter collection, it’s easy to see why I require a whole room.  My poor [...]

  6. [...] With all the cookie baking she does, you know Sweet Sugarbelle has to be at least somewhat organized. She uses plastic bins to separate her cookie cutters into categories. Kudos to her for taking the extra step of busting out the label maker! You can check out her system here. [...]

  7. [...] cookie sheets in favor of a pretty platter.  As you can see, I have a prop problem {to match my cutter and icing tip problem} but all you really need is one or two.  I recommend white because it goes [...]

  8. [...] Organizing and Storing Cookie Cutters [...]

  9. […] real life I have hundreds, maybe even thousands of cookie cutters.  I love my collection, but realistically there are very few that I use on a regular basis.  As a […]