How to Make Adorable Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies with a Dog Bone Cutter

How to make adorable PB&J cookies with a dog bone cutter via Sweetsugarbelle.comWhen it comes to decorated cookies, there’s no right or wrong way to approach a design. These peanut butter and jelly cookies are the perfect example.

I’ve made peanut butter and jelly cookies before, but this time I needed something a bit smaller, so, I took an entirely different route.

Cute Kawaii Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies via Sweetsugarbelle.comI’m sure it won’t surprise anyone to learn that I own a mini-toast cutter. I found it in a Christmas play dough set from Target last year and justified my purchase as stocking stuffers for the kids. Long story short, I paid way too much for the thing.

The initial plan was to then use my over-priced cutter to make these cookies, but when it came time to bake, it was a too “mini” for what I had in mind. So, I used a dog bone instead.

You can save time by cutting the dog bone in half, but for some reason, I was dead set on a rounder base. I’ve forgotten why it was so important now, but I ended up doing twice the work (my specialty) and trimmed the bottom with a moon cutter.

As always, I encourage you to do as I say, not as I do, and make life easier by letting the little things go.

ToastPeanut Butter and Jelly Cookie CutterAnyhow…to decorate these cookies you will need:

  • Light brown piping icing (warm brown+avocado+egg yellow)
  • Ivory flood icing
  • Purple flood icing
  • Light pink flood icing (a small amount)
  • Black sugar pearls
  • White flood icing (a small amount)
  • Black piping icing

Begin by outlining the cookie with a #3 tip.

How to Make Peanut Butter and Jelly Kawaii CookiesNext, use ivory icing to flood the area closest to the outside border, leaving an opening in the center for “jelly”. Be sure to work carefully and not overfill because in this case you want the brown outline to show.

How to Make Kawaii Peanut Butter and Jelly CookiesLet the ivory icing set (allow a little extra time if your icing tends to bleed) then fill in the center section with purple flood icing.

How to make peanut butter and jelly cookies via Sweetsugarbelle.comImmediately drop two pink dots into the wet icing.

How to cute peanut butter and jelly toast cookies via Sweetsugarbelle.comThen, quickly use tweezers to quickly add sugar pearl eyes.

How to make adorable peanut butter and jelly cookies with a dog bone cookie cutter via Sweetsugarbelle.comGive the cookie time to dry (this can take anywhere from four to twenty-four hours depending where you live) then use a #1.5 tip to pipe on a sweet little smile. You can also use a toothpick dipped in white icing to add a little highlight, if you like.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Kawaii CookiesTo make peanut butter toast, follow the same steps as above but substitute tan flood icing for the purple. Holy cuteness, right?

Peanut Butter Toast Cookie via Sweetsugarbelle.comAnd remember, almost anything (even poop) is cute when it smiles.

How to Make PB&J Cookies with a Dog Bone Cookie Cutter via Sweetsugarbelle.comPeanut butter and jelly kawaii cookies are great for Valentine’s Day, anniversaries, or even a surprise gift for your best friend. For more adorable cookie inspiration, be sure to check out these posts:

Rainbow Funfetti Cutout Cookie Recipe

Rainbow Funfetti Cookie Dough

If you haven't noticed by now by now, I LOVE color. Even when I try to keep things under control, my simple four color palettes often become eight...or more. Apparently this also applies to cookie dough. When I came across these rainbow sprinkles in Target's dollar bin, I knew what I had to do. Rainbow funfetti cutout cookies.  It's a beautiful thing. This isn't really a new recipe, just my basic sugar cookie recipe with sprinkles added. … continue reading

How to Make Mermaid Tail Cookies in Four Easy Steps

How to make easy mermaid tail cookies in four easy steps via Sweetsugarbelle.com

There are very few mythical creatures as beloved as the mermaid. From lonely, sea weary sailors, to carefree little girls, mermaids have captured the imagination of people worldwide. In my experience, decorated mermaid cookies can range from difficult to downright stressful, so if you're on the lookout for an easy mermaid cookie idea that even a beginner can manage, this project is for you. Mermaid tail cookies are perfect for new and … continue reading

Twenty Shark Cookie Ideas for Shark Week

Twenty fun and frightening (not really) shark cookie ideas for Shark Week via Sweetsugarbelle.com

In my house, after Christmas, Halloween, and birthdays, Shark Week is probably the most anticipated non-holiday event of the year. If you're looking at a busy week of shark watching like me, what better way to celebrate than with a few fun and frightening (only a little) decorated cookies? Here are twenty of my very favorite shark cookies, you know, because it's impossible to pick just one.  Enjoy! 1. Simple Shark Mouth Cookies 2. … continue reading

How to Make Mermaid Cookies with a Snowman Cutter

Learn to make mermaid cookies with a Wilton Snowman cutter at Sweetsugarbelle.com

A few weeks ago I did something I thought I'd never do. I went through my cookie cutter collection and got rid of the ones that I rarely use. Okay, before anyone faints, it wasn't quite that dramatic. I didn't actually get rid of them, I just put them into storage for awhile. We're preparing to move, and for some reason my realtor thought that a dining room was a better selling feature than a cookie cave. I know, I know...who wouldn't want … continue reading

How to Make Easy Hole in One Golf Cookies

Simple Golf Fairway Cookies Green Cookies via sweetsugarbelle.com

It's no secret that when it comes to golf, my knowledge is pretty limited.  In fact, I spent twenty minutes on Google before naming this post just to be sure I didn't embarrass myself. Anywho, I may stink at golf, but I try to make up for my complete and utter lack of knowledge with cute cookie ideas.  I hope it's working. Like many of my cookie designs, this one began life as a completely different cutter, in this case, a flip flop.  You … continue reading

20 Fun and Simple Decorated Cookies for Father’s Day

20 Fun and Simple Decorated Cookies for Father's Day via Sweetsugarbelle.com

  Over the years, Father's Day gifts have gotten a bad rap. It's time to change that. Dreaded old faithfuls like socks and ties go from "blah" to "ahhh" when they're delivered in cookie form. If you're on the lookout for a unique, handmade gift, Father's Day cookies are the perfect solution. Here are twenty fun and easy Father's Day cookie ideas for the special dad in your life! 1. Simple Golf Cookies 2. Cigar Cookies … continue reading

Decorated Hydrangea Cookies

How to make beautiful hydrangea cookies.

I had never seen hydrangeas before moving to Virginia at age seventeen, but the instant I laid eyes on those beautiful, colorful blooms, I fell forever in love. Now that I'm back home in Texas, "real" hydrangeas aren't a possibility, but for years I have dreamed of enjoying them again. So, I made my own hydrangeas, cookie-style. Many people believe that you need to own an airbrush system to create cookies like these, but that simply isn't … continue reading

Decorated Golf Cookies

Easy Golf Cookies via Sweetsugarbelle.com

Father's Day is coming soon, and in my world that means lots of cookies in the traditional themes. At the top of the list, golf cookies. To be honest, I don't know much about golf. I went to the driving range (I think that's what it's called) with a couple of friends in high school and after about three swings, one of them forbade me to touch her clubs. What a grouch, right? Most recently, my husband forced me to watch the Masters. After … continue reading

Twenty Decorated Flower Cookie Tutorials for Mother’s Day

Twenty beautiful decorated flower cookie tutorials for Mother's Day!

Being a mom is the hardest, most rewarding job I've ever had. The moment I looked into my son's eyes for the very first time, my life forever changed. Over the years, I've added a few more kiddos and a lot more hustle and bustle to every day life. As I go through each day, surrounded by almost non-stop noise and action, I've started to appreciate my own mother more. I have a much greater understanding of how much energy it took to raise three … continue reading