Decorated Peeps Cookies…in Disguise

Okay, okay, I admit it. I love Peeps. And not just the marshmallow kind, I love cookie Peeps too.

As a matter of fact, I love them so much that this is third time I’ve made them on this blog. Just when you thought you’d seen every possible spin on this old fave, I’m back with a new twist. Peeps cookies, in disguise!Decorated Peeps Cookies...in Disguise
Peeps in Disguise Cookies SweetsugarbelleOnce upon a time, if you wanted to make Peeps cookies, you had to get creative. These days, Wilton has you covered. You can now buy Peeps cutters in a variety of sizes. I used the smaller bunny from this set, but if you prefer larger cookies, these are the cutters for you.

To decorate these cookies you will need:

Begin by using a #2 tip to outline and fill the cookies as pictured below.

How to Make Peeps Cookies 1After a minute or two, use tweezers drop the decorations of your choice onto the wet icing. I’ve always been a sucker for nerdy glasses.

If necessary, reposition with a toothpick or 2-in-1 tool.

How to Make Peeps Cookies in DisguiseNext, give the icing a sprinkle of yellow sugar. Work quickly to ensure that it adheres to the cookie.

Word of advice, a thick layer of sugar can get pretty heavy. Be careful not to over-sprinkle or the icing may spill over the outline.

How to Make Peeps Cookies in Disguise 2When the cookie is completely dry (this can take anywhere from four to twenty-four hours, depending on where you live) use a soft brush to gently brush away any excess sugar.

Peeps Collage 5Use a small round tip (such as a #1 or #1.5) to add eyes and a nose (as pictured below), or in the case of the cookie above, just a nose, and there you have it, my third edition of decorated Peeps cookies!  Easy breezy, right?

How to Make Peeps Cookies 6These days Peeps come in every color under the sun, but my favorite combo will always be yellow, pink, and purple. What’s yours?

Wilton Peeps in Disguise Cookies SweetsugarbelleEaster just isn’t quite Easter without a healthy dose of Peep-tacular treats.  For more inspiration, check out the following links:

Disclaimer: As a member of the Wilton Sweet Treat Team, I received products and/or compensation for this post.  I am a long time user (and lover) of Wilton products.  I personally selected the products featured in this post.  All ideas and opinions are my own.

Easy Decorated Burlap Cookies

To most people, these probably look like burlap Easter bunny cookies.  But when I look at them, I see so much more.  I see...

Decorated Peeps Cookies

If you’re feeling like you’ve seen Peeps cookies here before, you’re absolutely right.  A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away…I made...

Polka Dot Carrot Cookies

Who’s the nut still taking about Easter?  Yeah, that would be me. I like Easter cookies as much as the next gal, but after...

Simple Delft Blue Easter Egg Cookies

I have always wanted to make Delft blue Easter eggs, but somehow, every year I’ve run out of time.  This year, I have the...

How to Make Snowman Cookies with a Paisley Cutter

You didn’t think I could share seven printable cookie decorating templates without a tutorial, did you? Of course not! I picked this adorable snowman,...

Printable Snowman Cookie Decorating Templates and Royal Icing Transfer Sheets

After the winter we’ve had, I think it’s a pretty safe bet that almost I hope everyone (or at least everyone in my little...

The Fourth Annual Twelve Days of Giving with Lila Loa and Sweet Sugarbelle, Day Twelve

I hope you’re sitting down, because day twelve is finally here, and the grand prize is sure to blow your mind! Today’s prize is...

Ralphie Cookies from “A Christmas Story”

“Oh, fudge!” There are only thirteen days until Christmas and so many cookies yet to be baked! That’s why I love ideas like this...

The Fourth Annual Twelve Days of Giving with Lila Loa and Sweet Sugarbelle, Day Eleven

It’s day eleven which also means just one more day until we reveal the final, grand prize. But, that doesn’t mean today will be...

The Fourth Annual Twelve Days of Giving with Lila Loa and Sweet Sugarbelle, Day Ten

Welcome to day TEN of the Fourth Annual Twelve Days of Giving! Can you believe we’re down to just three days left? Today’s prize...

The Fourth Annual Twelve Days of Giving with Lila Loa and Sweet Sugarbelle, Day Nine

Welcome to day nine of the Fourth Annual Twelve Days of Giving! There’s just a few more days left until our final, grand prize...