Brown Sugar Roll-Out Cookies {Recipe}

I have always wanted to host one of those holiday cookie swap parties, but when Christmas comes around it always seems like there is never enough time for me to get something organized.  So, this year when my friend Julie told me about The Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap I was very excited to sign up.

I received three names and  sent one dozen cookies to each person.  In return, I received three different boxes of cookies myself.  Not only was it fun to get cookies, I also REALLY enjoyed making three different sets of cookies to send out.

This was my favorite set…

One of the rules of the swap was that I use and publish a new recipe with my post, so I  thought it was the perfect time to drag out my brown sugar roll-out recipe.  The nice thing about these cookies is that you can make minor adjustments and completely change the cookie.  In this case I added a little orange flavoring and spice.  I call it “almost” gingerbread because it has a hint of gingerbread flavor but it’s still not quite gingerbread.

Brown Sugar Roll-Out Cookies

Yield: 2 1/2 dozen

Brown Sugar Roll-Out Cookies


  • 3/4 c. unsalted butter
  • 1 1/2 c. dark brown sugar
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 tbsp. milk, half and half, or orange juice
  • 2 tsp. extract or emulsion {I used orange and vanilla}
  • 1 tsp. baking powder
  • 1/2 tsp. baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp. salt
  • 3 c. all-purpose flour
  • 2 tsp. cinnamon {spices optional}
  • 1 tsp. nutmeg
  • dash ground cloves


  1. Cream together butter and sugar. Add eggs, extract, and orange juice. Mix until fluffy. Sift together dry ingredients a cupful or so at a time until all of the dry mixture is incorporated. The dough should be soft but not sticky. If it’s sticky, add flour little by little until it isn’t.
  2. Divide dough into three parts, wrap in plastic wrap and chill for at least 30 minutes.
  3. Roll to 1/4 inch thickness and cut into shapes. Dusting lightly with flour as needed.
  4. Bake 375 for 8-10 minutes until tops are not shiny.

For all of you weigh your ingredients…cross my heart I did this for you.  The problem is, I wrote the numbers on a tiny scrap of paper which of course got lost.  I even went as far into doing the dreaded trash can dig without any luck, but I will be making these again very soon, and I will redo the measurements as soon as possible.

If you aren’t a gingerbread lover leave out the spice, or use cinnamon only.  This is a very adaptable recipe and produces a rich, tasty cookie perfect for decorating or eating alone.

I hope everyone enjoyed their cookies as much as I enjoyed decorating them and I would also like to thank the lovely ladies that sent cookies to me last week.  It was a treat for the whole family.

Hopefully next year I can organize a real live cookie swap.  But until then, this is the next best thing!  I hope everyone has a wonderful week full of the Christmas spirit.

Only twelve more days until Christmas!  Are you ready?!

Join The Discussion



  1. 81
    Laura says:

    Made these cookies tonight and they taste awesome. What a great recipe. Can’t say that my icing designs will turn out as good as yours, but at least they will taste good! :)

  2. 82
    Tersa says:

    WOW!!! Those are THE most beautiful cookies I have ever seen!! I cannot wait to try this recipe as well as your other sugar cookie recipe. Thanks for posting!

  3. 83
    Veronica says:

    I am trying to use the recipe in here but every 5 minutes the website close and opens the Appstore trying to install one of those craby FREE games that seem to be malware, I just found this blog so useful, but I recommend you check with your webdesigner and the ads you are using.

  4. 84
    Jen says:

    Do you have a good icing recipe for these cookies? :-)

  5. 85
    sonia says:

    Hello Callye, I tried your recipe with some adjustment following my taste and the cookies were wonderful. This is the post of my blog, obviously I mentioned that the recipe was yours. Thank you and have a nice Christmas!

  6. 86
    Lane says:

    Thanks! I need a faux-gingerbread cutout recipe, and I was not excited about just tinting my usual recipe with brown coloring…. Making/decorating cookies for a crowd and not everyone loves gingerbread, you know :) THANKS!

  7. 87
    Rosalind Williams says:

    love this recipe..


  1. […] don’t recall how I came across the brown sugar cookie recipe. I stumbled across it while looking for a new recipe and just had to try it. I will say that the […]

  2. […] Brown Sugar Roll Out Cookies […]

  3. […] wasn’t even over and I was itching to bake Christmas cookies.  I really wanted to try Sweet Sugar Belle’s brown sugar recipe and loved the idea of rustic Christmas cookies so took inspiration from her post and made my own. […]

  4. […] The Santa Cookie that Started it All via Me Brown Sugar Roll Out Cookies by Sweet Sugar Belle […]